Commentary: Bird’s Invasion of Union Station Shows Need for Scooter Watchdog

Bird's aggressive placement of scooters at Union Station demonstrates Denver's lax enforcement of existing rules and the need of a watchdog agency to police scooter companies.

Bird contractors placed 13 scooters in the middle of a pedestrian thoroughfare at Union Station on Aug. 15. Photo: Andy Bosselman
Bird contractors placed 13 scooters in the middle of a pedestrian thoroughfare at Union Station on Aug. 15. Photo: Andy Bosselman

Denver needs a watchdog agency to police the scooter companies.

In recent weeks, the scooter company Bird has repeatedly placed groups of scooters, what it calls “Bird Nests,” in every imaginable outdoor corner of the station, including parking 13 scooters directly in the middle of a pedestrian thoroughfare on Aug. 15, a practice it has repeated until Streetsblog asked the company about it yesterday.

Mackenzie Long, a spokesperson for Bird, said the company’s policy is to be “respectful of the public right of way and all persons who use it,” but offered no comment on the clear violations that Streetsblog uncovered.

Under city law, scooters must “not impede the normal and reasonable movement of pedestrian or other traffic.” The scooter companies are also required to keep the vehicles from operating at Union Station through a technology known as geofencing.

Clearly, the city is enforcing neither regulation.

That should change. 

Scooters block a pedestrian thoroughfare again yesterday morning. Photo: Andy Bosselman
Scooters block a pedestrian thoroughfare again yesterday morning. Photo: Andy Bosselman

Mayor Michael Hancock and members of the City Council are leaving the city’s plazas, streets and sidewalks open to irresponsible exploitation. Instead of shrugging their shoulders and surrendering public spaces to the billionaire venture capitalists behind these companies, Denver officials should create a watchdog agency that will police the industry’s actions. 

This opinion may surprise Streetsblog readers. As a news site that covers the fight for safe, sustainable modes of transportation, we encourage Denver’s embrace of electric scooters. We believe our streets need to change to become better places for people to walk, bike and scoot. 

But government must step up to make sure companies consistently follow laws and regulations, just as it does at the federal level for meat, medications and motorcycle helmets. Like the Federal Drug Administration and the Department of Transportation before it, Denver should enforce scooter rules at the local level through a new scooter watchdog agency. 

Nine Bird scooters placed in the middle of a crosswalk at the Wewatta Street entrance to Union Station on Aug. 26. Photo: Andy Bosselman
Nine Bird scooters placed in the middle of a crosswalk at the Wewatta Street entrance to Union Station this morning. Photo: Andy Bosselman

The agency I’m proposing should: 

  • Have the teeth to issue fines that start at $5,000 and go well into the millions.
  • Be independent, to prevent the companies from influencing elected officials and city staff.
  • Have adequate staff to monitor the companies and issue citations, perhaps by requiring one enforcement agent for every 500 scooters.

Of course, scooter companies should fund the new agency through fees.

The need to step up enforcement of Big Tech’s impact on cities is already clear. Silicon Valley companies have already recklessly deployed their services in cities and won’t stop on their own, according to John Tinnell, a professor at CU Denver. He pointed out last month in Streetsblog and the Los Angeles Times: 

Like Uber and Airbnb before them, scooter companies aim to satisfy their customers with little regard for how their businesses affect our cities’ ecosystems. All three services tamper with neighborhood norms in ways that are annoying at first and deeply disturbing upon further inspection.

He goes on to point out how Uber and Lyft add more cars to the roads, increase traffic congestion and reduce ridership of public transportation. These impacts have frustrated Denver’s goal to reduce the number of people driving alone, obstructing related goals around mobility, pollution and the climate crisis.   

Tinnell also warns that allowing tech companies to do whatever they want with public spaces sets a dangerous precedent.

If cities continue to offer an anything-goes approach to Big Tech, there will be no regulatory and enforcement framework to accommodate the certain arrival of other technologies, like delivery robots and drones, he writes. And that would further what Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgo has called “anarchy in the streets.”


Streetsblog Denver informs the movement for sustainable transportation and a livable city. Give $5 per month.

  • iBikeCommute

    This seems wrong-headed. Start by removing car parking spaces around the station so there is space to park scooters and bikes that doesn’t impede pedestrians.

    • Jacklyn

      $6035 & $9910…….. These two paychecks I have obtained after my becoming a member of an on-line job almost 2 months earlier. I am not expert and not an on-line professional but still I am able to bring home 1000s monthly. This task is quite effortless and also its regular income are overwhelming. Let me show you what i do… ===> sni.to/4d

  • TakeFive

    Life is full of rich ironies. I couldn’t even count the number of hours I spent calling voters all over the country on behalf of Barack Obama. Silicon Valley and so-called Big Tech and the whole tech ecosphere were huge financial backers of Obama. Now, every time I turn around those same Democrats are demonizing the world of tech.

    All those gleaming new office towers and new space in Denver’s inspiring RiNo neighborhood are being filled by Denver’s growing VC backed tech companies. All those new apartments are filling up with young techie millennial’s. Is it now the case that those involved in tech including their investors are no longer welcome in the Democratic Party?

    If your specific concern is with Bird and you lust for a Bogeyman, the name is Travis VanderZanden.

  • Jim Haley

    I don’t like to see this. When sidewalks become impassable due to the number of scooters illegally stationed in the way, something has clearly gone wrong. That said, the fact that this occurred in the vicinity of Union Station makes certain amount of sense. The scooters are in place to service the so-called “first mile / last mile” niche which brings commuters to public transport hubs. I think that is a net positive. I like the idea of a regulatory body with teeth to impose fines but also agree with another poster who suggests finding space for these devices to be parked in a less intrusive fashion.

  • personalized1

    Streetsblog’s continued war on scooters is really puzzling to me. It’s only a matter of time before someone sees a bike parked badly and makes Trek pay for a government agency to be the watchdog over badly parked bikes everywhere.

  • LoDo Resident

    Here’s a simple answer that can be found elsewhere: If scooters are parked so as to interfere with ped access or wheelchair access, they are fair game for impoundment, either by the City or by city-empowered towing services. The scooter companies can then reclaim such units at the impound yards for a fee to be set by Council. One additional suggestion — all scooters shall have an I.D. number attasched which shall be readable from – say – 25′ away in any direction, so as to make law-breakers easily identifiable, by police or citizens. A time-stamped photo of, say, two people on a scooter riding down the middle of a sidewalk should be ample proof for a warning to be issued.

  • LazyReader

    Bird’s aggressive placement of scooters at Union Station demonstrates
    That denverites would rather ride cheap scooters than take the trains.

    • mckillio

      No, it doesn’t.

  • bobthebuilder

    My only question is; where shall they park them?

    Rather than use fee’s for watch dogs, why don’t we use that money to expand non automobile infrastructure.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The UN secretary general, António Guterres, addresses the closing meeting of the 73rd session of the United Nations general assembly at the UN headquarters on 16 September. Photograph: Xinhua/Rex/Shutterstock

‘We’re Losing the Race’: UN Secretary General Calls Climate Change an ‘Emergency’

|
This story originally appeared in The Guardian. It is republished here as part of Streetsblog’s partnership with Covering Climate Now, a global collaboration of more than 300 news outlets to strengthen coverage of the climate story. The UN secretary general says that he is counting on public pressure to compel governments to take much stronger action against what […]
6763903825_426b83089c_b
STREETSBLOG USA

Car-Free Zones Eyed in SF, Elsewhere

|
A string of pedestrian injuries and deaths in San Francisco’s Tenderloin district has spurred city leaders to demand a ban on cars in some densely populated neighborhoods — the latest in a nascent and long-overdue move by activists nationwide to get reckless drivers off at least a tiny handful of city streets. San Francisco Supervisor […]
A Comcast Xfinity van tips over within eyeshot of where cyclist Alexis Bounds was killed July 24. Photo: Anonymous

Wednesday’s Headlines

|
Dangerous place: A photo shows an Xfinity van rolling over near the ghost bike placed in remembrance of Alexis Bounds. Input sought for Front Range Passenger Rail. The five options CDOT is considering to upgrade I-25 in Denver. More headlines ...