RTD’s Driver Shortage Is Getting Worse, and It’s Untenable

Service cuts possible as RTD continues to struggle with new hires.

Photo: David Sachs
Photo: David Sachs

People riding RTD buses and trains are not getting where they need to go on time — if at all — because RTD does not have enough drivers to take them there.

As Streetsblog reported in September, the underfunded transit agency cannot hire and retain enough people to drive all of its scheduled routes.

The problem is getting worse. August saw 775 hours worth of bus runs that should’ve happened but didn’t, RTD documents show. That figure doubled in September. October saw 1,105 lost hours — a 67 percent increase over the same month last year.

While RTD still delivers about 99 percent of its promised service, that’s not good enough, said Bruce Abel, assistant general manager of bus operations.

“Statistically it looks okay, but when you’re Mrs. Smith stranded at the corner of 8th and Oak and your bus doesn’t come by, it doesn’t look okay,” Abel said during an RTD Board of Directors meeting Tuesday.

The agency is short 127 bus drivers and 47 train operators.

RTD has tried drawing in more drivers with more money over the last year-and-a-half: a $1-per-hour raise, a $2-per-hour bonus for drivers who work two nonconsecutive shifts in one day, a $2,000 signing bonus, and a $1,000 bonus for drivers who refer new employees.

But these incentives haven’t changed the bottom line. Driving a bus or a train is apparently not all that attractive in a metro Denver job market where only 2.2 percent of residents are unemployed.

The result is RTD drivers working on their days off to try an satisfy the bus schedules, making the job even less desirable.

“When you get behind in terms of head count, then you must mandate more employees,” Abel said. “As employees get mandated, they find it less appealing, so they will leave, which means that your head count shortage is exacerbated, and so it becomes a vicious spiral.”

About 10 percent of daily bus runs are covered by drivers working overtime.

“We need to pay these people more money,” District K Director Paul Solano said.

Legal weed could also deter applicants, Abel said. Drivers must get drug tested under federal law, and he suspects that’s a disincentive.

Service cuts are on the table, Abel said, though he called that possibility “right-sizing.”

Getting to a Broncos game vs. getting to work

Hauling people to and from Mile High Stadium with the BroncosRide service on a Sunday night can mean problems for commuters come Monday morning. Lost service hours spike at the start of the National Football League season and when the Broncos play home games, RTD documents show. The system gets stretched thin from the surge in demand, thinning out the Monday workforce.

Broncos games are not the problem — everyone should be able to take transit when and where they need to. But RTD is facing a budget crunch on top of the driver shortage, and the FasTracks expansion approved in 2004 is not even complete. Meanwhile state lawmakers may or may not restore $6 million in annual revenue lost to a typo.

Without any additional funding, something’s gotta give.

District I Director Judy Lubow said shifting service from the BroncosRide to commuter routes is “definitely worth a discussion.” At the same time, a packed bus is a more productive use of money than a half-empty one.

“Our mission is to move people, not vehicles,” Abel said.

  • Rob Durchola

    The problem is not unique to Denver. I am retired from a large East Coast transit agency and when the economy was improving and there was low unemployment, qualified bus and rail operators were in short supply.

    The agency is currently heavily recruiting operating personnel. That and notices of canceled trips on the agency’s website suggest that there is a real shortage of bus and rail operators currently.

  • TakeFive

    If applicants didn’t have to pass a drug screen RTD could probably get triple the applications. Not much RTD can do about that. Given the budget backdrop I’d suggest doing more rather than less “rightsizing.” That will make a significant dent to the driver shortage.

    Insider info informs that between the middle of 2016 and 2017, RTD ridership was down over 15%. APTA figures for this year through the 2nd quarter show RTD ridership down about 5%. Ridership on the A Line was up over a 150% or it would have looked worse.

    RTD is just now addressing what many transit agencies across the country have been dealing with as they cut lower ridership routes. It isn’t likely that RTD’s budget will improve measurably for some time; they just need to do what they need to do.

  • Rich Cummings

    O boy, a whole dollar raise! Thats why you’re not getting drivers. Simply don’t pay well enough to attract the New Employee. Period. I dont care what “others” pay. RTD needs to pay more. BTW, the turnover must be huge! Wonder why?

  • Greg

    Here’s the problem with RTD and I know because I was hired back in 2012 after closing my business…

    I wanted to be a train operator badly but you first must drive a bus for 3-6 months. I was willing to accept the hourly pay rate and started my 6 weeks of training.

    Within the first weeks, one of the instructors kept repeating over and over again how once trained and being new we’d have to accept routes that nobody wanted (Colfax, Montbello etc).

    The instructor repeatedly stated that on these routes because we might be running late etc that some riders would purposely spill hot coffee in our laps or spit in our faces.

    He went on to tell us repeatedly that there were cameras everywhere and if we said anything to the rider, got up out of our seat or so much as “rolled our eyes”, we’d be fired!

    After hearing this for a couple of days, I commented in training class that I’d just started going back to church a couple of years ago but I didn’t claim to be “Jesus” and that I thought spitting in someone’s face was a misdemeanor. He replied in the class that I could “call my dispatch but they’d tell me to wipe my face and keep driving”!

    I quit on the spot! Any employer that allows a class of their employees to be treated like this doesn’t deserve employees period! The transit system in Atlanta, MARTA, certainly would not tolerate this behavior from any rider and RTD shouldn’t either!

    Hopefully they’ve changed this policy since then but if not, all I can say is good luck finding the help you need!

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Today’s Headlines

|
Drivers Killed More Pedestrians Than Ever in Colorado Last Year (Herald) Police to Double Down on High Driving Enforcement 4/20 (Cannabist) Elyria Swansea Residents Remain Skeptical of Stormwater Project Tied to I-70 Widening (Denverite) Poll: 35 Percent of Denverites Love Idea of Hosting Amazon Headquarters — 16 Percent Hate It (Denverite) …But Boston or D.C […]

Today’s Headlines

|
CDOT: Nearly 70 Percent of Pot Smokers Drove High Last Year (Coloradoan) High Winds Cause RTD Delays (Patch) Denverite Readers Weigh In on What It Would Take to Be a “24-Hour City” DU Professor Says Uber Driver Tried to Abduct Her (9News) Poudre School District Can’t Staff Enough Bus Drivers (Coloradoan) National headlines at Streetsblog […]