Takeaways From a Ride on RTD’s B-Line, Denver’s Newest Rail Route

DSC_0613
Photo: David Sachs

RTD is having a busy 2016, and it continued Monday with the opening of the B-Line between Westminster and Union Station.

The commuter rail line gets people between downtown and Westminster in 11 minutes. It arrives every 30 minutes during peak hours (5:50 – 8:30 a.m. and 3:20 – 7:30 p.m.) and every hour the rest of the day. The train, which costs $2.60 one-way, does not stop between downtown and its northern suburb.

I hopped on the B-Line at Union Station yesterday afternoon, took the quick trip to Westminster Station, and walked around for a bit. Here are some takeaways.

There are two stations along the B-Line that the train does not serve.

Flying by at 79 mph, the train passed two RTD stations. Those are the Pecos Junction and 41st and Fox stations — part of the G-Line, scheduled to open this fall. You’d think both the B and G Lines would utilize the stops. Doing so would mean trains come more frequently, and higher frequency grows ridership by providing shorter wait times and flexibility for riders.

Screen Shot 2016-07-26 at 11.33.25 AM
The B-Line and the G-Line share a track, but don’t share stops. Image: RTD

This setup limits how people can use the line. Say a family lives near Pecos Junction and wants to take the train to Westminster a few miles north. They would have to hop on the G-Line, travel south to Union Station, transfer to the B-Line, and head back north to Westminster Station — passing their origin point on the way. How many people will choose to do that?

Nate Currey, an RTD spokesperson, said the transit agency had to designate the G and B lines as separate corridors to satisfy a billion-dollar-plus grant from the Federal Transit Administration. RTD has “every intention of reviewing our system a year after it opens,” Currey said. We could eventually see both lines serve those stops, he said. (Looking further ahead, however, if the B-Line is ever fully built out to Boulder, those stops will probably get bypassed to save time.)

DSC_0694
Photo: David Sachs

The train was standing room only in both directions, and it was a fast trip.

Lots of people used the B-Line on opening day, and many carried shopping bags and carts like they were running daily errands, not just taking a ride for the novelty. The trip each way was 11 minutes on the dot. (Google Maps says it’s a 25-minute drive station to station.) Still, RTD estimates the B-Line’s average ridership will be just 800 passengers per weekday this year. Which does make sense, when you consider the land use around Westminster Station…

DSC_0622
With 350 mostly free parking spaces, who wouldn’t drive to Westminster Station? Photo: David Sachs

Cars and parking are king at Westminster Station.

Westminster Station is another example of RTD’s penchant for building drive-to transit. The RTD parking garage has 350 stalls for car storage and RTD plans to add 650 more. A privately run lot has 250 spots for a total of 600. There are 20 bike racks and 18 bike lockers. Two RTD bus lines serve the station — the 72 and the 31 — with service every 30 minutes.

A brand new street, Westminster Station Drive, was constructed to connect Federal Boulevard to the station. But it only has a sidewalk on one side. Sidewalks in the neighborhood closest to the station are just three feet wide. The street does have bike lanes and a Zagster bike-share station, but nearby Federal Boulevard — a speedway under Colorado DOT’s jurisdiction — impedes the bikeability of the neighborhood.

DSC_0626
Neighborhood streets by the station have skinny, rollover sidewalks. Photo: David Sachs

Westminster Station does not anchor a walkable area — at least not yet.

Westminster Station is not surrounded by compact development with a mix of housing, retail, and office space that can be easily accessed on foot. The main feature is a 40-acre park that doesn’t exist yet (currently it’s just a lot of dirt). The park paths will connect a neighborhood of single-family homes to the station, but will also act as a buffer. A few low-rise apartment buildings sit near the station’s north side, but the closest neighbor is actually a sprawling RV dealership. There are only 300 residential units and 130 jobs with the 135 acres surrounding the station, according to the Denver Business Journal.

DSC_0669
The 40-acre park under construction. Photo: David Sachs

One development is in the pipeline: A 70-unit affordable housing project with retail and office space on the lower floors at 71st and Federal. The city of Westminster imagines a “vibrant, mixed-use district” around the station, but it will be a while before that vision becomes reality. The city is just now working on a land use plan for the area.

  • John Riecke

    A “vibrant, mixed-use district” that’s 30% parks with 1300 parking spaces? If I may steal a quote, “You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.” Suburban city leaders seem to have a hard time grasping the concept of TOD.

    • JerryG

      Since most of these lines are built along freight rail corridors, there is usually not much existing anything around those stations except some low density industrial. Westminster does have TOD plan, and it is of decent if moderate density, but I agree with you about the park being right next to the station. That should have been a block or two further away and denser development right at the station.

      • neroden

        Once you get further north on the B line (to the unfunded part), it’s an old enough railroad line that the cities were built around it. But you have to get to Broomfield and Louisville for that; Westminster is barely out of the ex-industrial land.

        The G line will do a bit better because cities were built around it.

  • disqus_1ovoN8fGFr

    Just to clarify, the B Line’s top speed is actually 60mph.

  • Thank you for highlighting the significant miss of the train stopping at the 41st & Fox Station and the Pecos Junction station. This seems a horribly poor decision for so many reasons. I sincerely hope the “review” mentioned by RTD is genuine and not just a deflection. I am grossly disappointed at this decision by RTD. Please share your thoughts directly with RTD Director ernest.archuleta@rtd-denver.com.

    • JerryG

      Until the 41st and Fox Station area is built out, there is not that much need for the B Line to stop there. However, the 41st/Fox station area will change and it can (potentially) have some high density. Hopefully, RTD will keep looking at that or at least the City of Denver should.

      • Thanks Jerry, how about all the residents of the Globeville and Sunnyside neighborhoods who want to travel to Westminster or to Union Station? Plenty of riders already exist. Also, not sure if you have seen this pending development… http://www.businessden.com/2016/07/22/globeville-property-sells-for-13m/

        • JerryG

          Pending development. Once plans are approved, then typical developments take a minimum of 18 months to complete. So probably looking at ~2 yrs from now before completion. There is some time. I don’t know, and likely you don’t know, how residents of Globeville or Sunnyside will want to travel to the Westminster station. Remember, Westminster station is also under development. So right now, I don’t think there is enough need for direct travel between those two stations. Right now. A year or two from now; maybe. I certainly hope so.

    • neroden

      RTD should be able to get a dispensation from the Feds to stop at the intermediate stations. Because there’s no reason not to.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Today’s Headlines

|
Of Course GOP Lawmakers Will Push New Transpo Bill Focused on Highway Expansion (DBJ) …In the Meantime, Thank Sens. Tate, Neville, and Hill for Traffic (Sentinel) Following Lawsuit, RTD to Retrofit Light Rail Cars for Wheelchairs (DenPo) Note to NIMBYs: People Have to Live Somewhere (9News) Eight-Story Building in West Colfax Will Have 56 For-Sale […]

Today’s Headlines

|
The Freeway-First Transport Tax Bill Is Dead (DenPo, DBJ) … But More Road-Focused Measures May Be Coming (Denverite) City May Now Bond $900 Million for Transport, Other Projects (DenPo) Illogically, Crashes and Congestion Have CDOT Talking Eight-Lane I-25 (DenPo) Driver Seriously Injures Person Walking at Sixth and Speer (DenPo) Driver Killes 62-Year-Old Man in the […]
Denver Public Works crews install a protected bike lane on 14th Avenue. Photo: David Sachs

Here Comes the 14th Ave Protected Bike Lane

|
Denver Public Works crews began installing a protected bike lane on West 14th Avenuee this week, the first new protected bikeway of 2017. It should be ready to ride by next week. The bikeway, which replaces a standard, striped bike lane, will run for a half-mile between Speer Boulevard and  Bannock Street — or about […]